but good: Idiom Meaning and Origin

The idiom "but good" is an American English expression that is commonly used in informal conversations and writing. It is recognized and understood by English speakers, especially in the United States.

One way "but good" is used is to intensify a physical action. It means doing something thoroughly or completely. For example, if someone says, "I cleaned the house but good," it means they cleaned the house very thoroughly.

The idiom can also emphasize the magnitude or extent of an event, usually with a negative connotation. It suggests that something has happened to a significant degree or with serious consequences. For instance, if someone says, "I messed up my car but good," they mean the car is severely damaged.

The origin and etymology of the idiom "but good" are not well-documented. However, it is clear that "but" in this context serves as an intensifier, conveying thoroughness or magnitude.

While primarily used in American English, variations of this expression exist in other English-speaking countries. In British English, a similar phrase "but well" is sometimes used. The core meaning remains consistent - intensifying an action or outcome.

The idiom "but good" is widely understood and used in American English to intensify an action or emphasize the magnitude of an event. Its usage is informal and prevalent in everyday conversations. Although the origin and etymology of the idiom are unclear, its meaning and usage are well-established. The versatility and impact of the idiom continue to make it a vibrant part of the English language.

The idiom "but good" is related to the idioms "well and good," "all good," and "a good deal."

"Well and good" is an idiomatic phrase that means everything is satisfactory or acceptable. It often implies agreement or approval. While "but good" intensifies an action or outcome, "well and good" expresses contentment or agreement.

"All good" is another idiomatic expression that means everything is fine, satisfactory, or resolved. It is often used to reassure someone that there are no problems or concerns. While "but good" emphasizes an action or event, "all good" indicates a positive outcome or situation.

"A good deal" is a phrase that signifies a favorable or advantageous situation or offer. It implies that something is of high value or worth. While "but good" intensifies an action or outcome, "a good deal" highlights the positive aspects or benefits of a particular situation or offer.

The idioms "well and good," "all good," and "a good deal" share similarities with "but good" in that they convey positive or satisfactory meanings. However, each idiom has its unique context and implications within everyday conversations.