pie-in-the-sky: Idiom Meaning and Origin

What does ‘pie-in-the-sky’ mean?

The idiom "pie-in-the-sky" refers to something that is unrealistic or unlikely to happen. It describes a situation or idea that may seem appealing or enticing, but is not practical or achievable in reality.

Idiom Explorer

Delusional Aspirations

The idiom "pie-in-the-sky" is a commonly-used expression in English. It means something that is unrealistically optimistic or overly idealistic. The phrase originated in the early 20th century and has since become popular to convey a sense of unattainability or impracticality.

The exact origin of the idiom is uncertain, but it is believed to come from the idea of the sky or heavens as a place of perfect happiness or ideal conditions. "Pie" is used metaphorically to represent something desirable or pleasurable. Combining these elements creates the image of a pie that is so delicious and tempting it appears to be floating in the sky, out of reach.

I wish for a pie to fall from the sky.

One possible source of the expression is the song "The Preacher and the Slave," written by labor activist Joe Hill in 1911. The song includes the line "You'll get pie in the sky when you die," which is often interpreted as a criticism of religious promises of reward in the afterlife instead of addressing immediate earthly concerns. This usage may have contributed to the idiom's connotation of unrealistic expectations or promises.

Over time, "pie-in-the-sky" has become firmly established in English, appearing in various contexts ranging from everyday conversation to literary works and media. It is often used to criticize or express skepticism towards overly optimistic or impractical ideas, plans, or promises. The idiom serves as a caution against placing too much faith in unrealistic or unattainable goals.

Like many idioms, "pie-in-the-sky" conveys a specific concept beyond its literal meaning. It symbolizes a desire or dream that is unattainable or unlikely to be realized. The idiom reminds us of the importance of being realistic and practical in our expectations and goals.

While the idiom has a firmly established meaning, its usage and interpretation may vary in different contexts and cultures. It remains a powerful and evocative way to convey the concept of unrealistic optimism or idealism. It invites us to consider the limitations of our aspirations and the importance of grounding our dreams in reality.

Example usage

Example 1:

The politician made a lot of promises during his campaign, but most people now see them as mere pie-in-the-sky dreams.

Example 2:

My friend always talks about starting his own business and becoming a millionaire, but it's just pie-in-the-sky thinking without a solid plan.

Example 3:

Although the idea of world peace is admirable, many consider it to be nothing more than a pie-in-the-sky concept that is unlikely to be achieved.

More "Hope" idioms